I didn’t find this surprising: Yes, Virginia, There Is A Culture War.
This comes from Dr. Dean Edell. I know for two reasons, A) he is the only nationally syndicated MD on the radio, and B) I have listened to him and know he is rather Liberal.
A national syndicated radio medical-advice show host recently reported on the findings of a study on the effectiveness of group therapy in treating depression. The most interesting finding of the study, he said, was that group therapy was found to be effective for women, but not for men.
I believe this, not because of any study, but through practical experience. I have always been uneasy in group therapy sessions and I do not find them as having any value to me.
But here’s the interesting part:
I don’t know about you, but I did not find that to be a shocker. What did shock me was the conclusion the talk show host drew from this finding. Before I divulge what that was, I would ask you to consider the finding, assume its validity, and decide what should be the next step, given that depressed women benefit from group therapy and depressed men do not.
Would you conclude that
A) we should seek other ways to treat depression in men
or
B) we should teach men to share their feelings more?
Depending on your answer, I’ll bet I can guess your political leaning and your opinion on a whole host of apparently unrelated issues. (This ability to divine a person’s thoughts from one opinion is not a gift of mine, but something I have learned from Thomas Sowell’s book “Conflict of Visions.”)
What is your choice? I think mine should be obvious given my views on things, especially since I’ve been through this firsthand as well.
I’m not going to give the answer away, you’ll just have to read the article to get the answer.
These differences of opinion are repeated in matters large and small in every aspect of our social and political life. They derive from conflicting views of the human condition and they are an example of what the culture war is about. These conflicting views are what this election is about and why we are more divided than we have been perhaps since the election of 1864.
For those of you who are history deprived, 1864 was the darkest days of the Civil War, when President Lincoln was trying to get reelected. It was when the country was split into two pieces, and even the Union side was beginning to split over the cost of the war, in materials, taxes and lives. It was only through the strength, determination and sheer will that Lincoln held the Union together. We owe so much to that one man.
But I digress. Read the article to find out which side of the fence you are on.